Used to be good - Anonymous employee Gusto Employee Review

1.0
22 Apr 2016
Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

You're working with very smart people who become your close friends. Free meals, and a great product which is truly working to revolutionize the broken payroll/HR industry.

Cons

Expectations for employees are well above what is possible due to product limitations, constantly changing personnel and direction. Employees are not set up for success and live in fear of being let go at any moment despite good performance. Management is like an old boys club of Ivy league grads and heavy favoritism plays a part into who gets opportunities versus who does not. This is not at all a meritocracy. Gusto drills it's values into every employee's head to where you could recite them in your sleep, but in the past 8 months, actually living up to these values has all but been abandoned. The commonly recited slogan is "Humans are not resources" though this is EXACTLY how employees are treated. I agree with every single critical review here and as you can see there is a running theme. You can't expect for the company to do well, and for employees to be passionate about company goals when employees themselves are not treated properly. There is very little recognition for success, but if you're not doing well, don't expect to be given any feedback or even keep your job. The facade of culture and community is trumped by an underlying sense of resentment that is growing amongst employees, and management and the people team seem to refuse to admit or recognize this. There is absolutely zero career development and the lack of titles does not set up anyone for success for the future of their career. I understand this was done to avoid egos developing internally, but there are definitely huge egos within Gusto that have nothing to do with job title. Many employees are overqualified for their job titles, and not given any room to grow within the company. All management and upper level positions are posted on our career website, no promoting from within.

avatar
Gusto Response
10y
Thank you for taking the time to share your views, and I’m sorry that your experience at Gusto did not live up to expectations. We take these reviews incredibly seriously, and are appreciative of folks who share their opinion on what is and is not working. While not perfect, and there is still a long journey ahead of us with much to be done, we hope we are taking steps in the right direction. In the last 8 months, your team went through a lot of change - changes in leadership & goals, and understandably, that led to concerns, which we have taken to heart. In that same timeframe, career levels, attributes, and performance development have been launched and we continue to collect feedback to improve them. We continue to focus on better strategic planning, goals setting, hiring of experienced leadership, and development of existing leadership. If you have ideas that you’d like to share, please do! While you are no longer at the company, you are still part of the Gusto community and your opinion is very much appreciated.

Explore other reviews about Gusto

5.0
10 Jun 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Smart and friendly coworkers. Excellent team culture

Cons

Tunnel visions on AI a bit too much

2.0
20 May 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

The product is genuinely good, too bad the same can’t be said for how they treat the people who sell it.

Cons

Leadership talks a big game about people-first culture but the reality doesn’t match. The Chicago office expansion felt like a poorly thought-out experiment, new hires were brought on without a clear long-term commitment, and layoffs came without warning, leaving people blindsided. Crossing a billion dollars in revenue and still cutting employees sends a clear message about where workers rank on the priority list. Remote work flexibility is also a glaring weakness. For a company selling HR software to modern businesses, their internal stance on where employees can work is surprisingly rigid and hypocritical. The “flexibility” messaging is mostly optics. The broader concern is the AI roadmap. The automation push feels less like an innovation strategy and more like a slow wind-down of the workforce. Employees aren’t blind to it, it creates anxiety and erodes trust. The culture of transparency they promote externally is largely a facade internally.

9
See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All