Worthy mission, subpar execution - Sales Mentor Collective Employee Review

3.0
10 Oct 2022
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Hard working coworkers who are thoughtful, kind, and experts in higher ed Good benefits Intellectually stimulating work Good work life balance for most depts & DEI is valued on all levels Completely remote & flexible PTO that you are encouraged to take

Cons

Overall the Mentor Collective team works hard for a worthwhile mission, but the main challenge is that the product is merely a band-aid for much larger systemic challenges that higher ed is facing right now and which tech-enabled mentorship simply cannot fix quickly. This translates into a challenging (and often frustrating) work environment where it can feel impossible to hit sales quotas and satisfy customers’ needs. A recent overhaul of leadership has probably improved the business outlook somewhat, but it also resulted in a slew of layoffs, even after reassuring staff multiple times that the company was in a good place financially after the recent Series A funding. The lack of transparency was astonishing. Early employees saw a lot of career growth, but later employees were promised a growth trajectory that is no longer possible. This has resulted in a lot of under-qualified middle managers who lack expertise and people management skills. Unfortunately, management also tends to hire overqualified applicants fleeing higher ed or non-profits because they know that they can underpay them. It's understandable, but also feels slimy.

Explore other reviews about Mentor Collective

5.0
26 Feb 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Lots of good people that work there

Cons

Lots of changes. Can be an option to scale up

4.0
25 Dec 2025
Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Mentor Collective has a strong mission and meaningful potential for impact in education and workforce development. Many employees were/are deeply invested in the work and committed to helping the organization succeed. Which made this a great company to work for.

Cons

During my latter time at Mentor Collective, leadership quality — rather than strategy, mission, or market conditions — became a significant barrier to retaining talent. Several senior leaders created environments marked by favoritism, inconsistent decision-making, and low psychological safety. As a result, strong, high-performing employees disengaged or left, not because of normal organizational transition, but because of leadership dynamics. These leadership patterns led to repeated turnover, disruption across teams, and the loss of institutional knowledge during a critical growth period. The impact on morale and execution was noticeable and avoidable. Recent leadership changes reflect challenges that were visible to staff well before they were addressed structurally.

See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All