Not the Company it Used to Be - Senior Recruiter Cielo Employee Review

1.0
5 Sept 2023
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

You can get promoted quickly by knowing the right people (not even necessarily by being good at your job). Working remotely is wonderful. IF you can manage your time/calendar well, you will have a good work/life balance. Unlimited PTO policy can be a plus to some. In theory, there is availability to move amongst teams and try out different industries. If you get on a good team, you can really build some life-long friendships. In all my time with Cielo, supporting five different client accounts, the clients are great (for the most part)! The partnerships were honestly the best part about my job - I still communicate with hiring managers from 3, 5, 8, 10 years ago.

Cons

All that being said, this is NOT the company it was when Sue Marks was the owner/CEO. Since being sold to an investment firm, things have gone downhill - most evident in the last ten months to a year (which is tough, because the senior leaders ARE good, and WERE good under Sue's leadership, and WILL be good again...at another company...). Now it is all about the bottom line, which is not being met, and all semblance of culture has gone out the window. Layoffs are happening constantly, and (at least on the team I was on/teams I know people on) there seems to be no rhyme/reason as to whom gets the ax. Top performers and fantastic leaders have been laid off since January, with more to come; replaced by workers overseas and inexperienced/unprepared leaders. All the turmoil and change is leading to clients leaving/pulling back work at an alarming rate. Employees that have no business being leaders yet are being promoted to Client Service Managers and managing multiple client accounts, so Cielo's whole 'we become you' thing is out the window, because the knowledge base is also out the window. It's honestly heartbreaking to see a company that was so great turn so quickly. The culture is GONE, replaced by fear, micromanagement, and overwork for those that don't get laid off. Since layoffs are company wide, and the only open positions appear to be in the Philippines/Mexico, it is really tough for those that get a lay off notice to find another team, or for internals to move teams in general now. Unlimited PTO seems like a cool concept, but really is just a ploy so they don't have to pay out unused PTO when people leave. Pay has always been pretty far below industry standard, with most people that leave getting 10-30K more at whatever new position they take, but the culture was always what managed to keep people around. Not so much anymore. It's just very sad to see something Sue worked so hard to build come to this, and for so many tenured employees to be leaving (most on their own accord, as they have seen the writing on the wall)... I say all this as someone not impacted by the layoffs, so this is not a bitter revenge review, it is just my honest viewpoint as someone who has been around since almost the beginning.

avatar
Cielo Response
2y
Hi there, this is Marissa Geist, CEO. Believe it or not, I read every one of these reviews and this one is pretty disheartening. You’re right that this isn’t the company it was. In fact, I can say that I think we’ve been a different company every year, at least for the past four years. It’s not an excuse – just fact – that since the pandemic hit in March 2020, our business has evolved significantly every single year as a result of the market’s response to circumstances beyond our control. Through all of the change, though, much of what we’re proud of has remained the same. Our commitment to providing better talent experiences for all, the development opportunities we offer, internal mobility, our willingness to be transparent through forums like unscripted town halls, coffee chats, listening sessions, and more. Our people remain committed to not only providing better experiences at work, but also in their communities. What we see them doing as volunteers and in partnership with Celebrate Cielo is inspiring, as is their support for one another. And despite having to reset as we navigate this post-pandemic world, our client renewal rates are stable and our partners are excited about the new products & services we’ve developed this year. We’re going to be ready…together…to shine when the market returns. Your more than 20 years of experience do not go unnoticed and I want to celebrate that for you. You’ve seen this company go through a lot during your tenure, and each time there’s been a downturn, our people, our culture, and our client partners have come out the other end of it stronger than ever. I’m disappointed that you left feeilng the way that you do, but I’m confident that what’s to come will make Sue proud and as a current member of our Board of Directors, she’s one of our biggest cheerleaders. I’m open to talking more if you are. It’s hard to have a great exchange on this anonymous platform, but you can contact me anytime at Marissa.Geist@cielotalent.com. I wish you the best in your next chapter.

Explore other reviews about Cielo

5.0
27 May 2026
Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Great management and WFH is nice

Cons

Hiring takings weeks and confusing start

4.0
4 Jun 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Management, pay, keeps you busy with meaningful work

Cons

Over hiring, layoffs, open communication of such issues

See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All